Man or Bear at Summerhall. Photo by Hugo Glendinning

Man or Bear | Summerhall

Years ago, I attended a Bon Jovi concert at the O2 Arena in London. I don’t remember the exact wording used, but Jon Bon Jovi took a moment to acknowledge the audience and encourage them to remember that the very best support comes from one another, and not so much from external agencies. This play covers a lot of ground without feeling overly rushed, and also considers what happens when those closely-knit support networks turn out not be quite so supportive after all.

Man or Bear at Summerhall. Photo by Hugo Glendinning
Man or Bear at Summerhall. Photo by Hugo Glendinning

Having called the show Man or Bear, it seemed evident to me that the production felt it necessary to stick with the concept, with the proceedings interspersed with a cast member putting on a bear costume. “Man or bear”, or “man vs bear” refers to a social media question, originally posed on a TikTok video in April 2024. The question was asked of eight women, “Would you rather be stuck in a forest with a man or a bear?” Seven picked the bear. The subsequent arguments in support of the seven included male violence against women, and the perception that a woman who says she was attacked by a bear is likelier to be believed than a woman who says she was attacked by a man.

Paige (Katie Hurley) has been able to escape the clutches of Sam, an unseen character, and alongside her daughter Angel (Amaia Naima Anguinaga) she is taken in by Connie (Lesley Ewen), but to make a temporary arrangement more permanent needs a deposit and a month’s rent. Paige manages to secure shifts at a local pub apparently hiring in this economy. Angel, still at secondary school, displays some behaviours quite typical of the archetypal ‘moody teenager’, and there’s an intriguing subplot about Connie finding love but encountering traditionalist views in her local church. A certain parishioner insists Connie, her new partner, and all lesbians, are going to Hell.

I didn’t think the selective use of microphones did very much in a studio space: some of the more foreboding aspects of the story took place sans amplification. In some respects, the narrative arc is a path well-trodden, although clearly, it’s one that needs to be travelled along even more as the world continues to be a frightening place for women and girls. The show’s conclusion is both harrowing and realistic, and I’d like to think I began to understand why most women would rather be alone in the woods with a grizzly bear than a bloke. A thoughtful and nuanced production.

4 star

Review by Chris Omaweng

Blending kitchen sink realism, music and bold physical sequences, Man or Bear follows the changing fortunes of a mother and teenage daughter who find refuge with a stranger. And then there’s the bear. As the story hurtles towards its devastating conclusion, audiences are drawn into the fierce, funny brilliance of these women. This is a story of resilience, humour and solidarity, offering a poetic and unsettling reflection on modern day misogyny.

Angel/Virgin – Amaia Naima Anguinaga
Connie/Crone – Lesley Ewen
Paige/Mother – Katie Hurley

Created by Katie Hurley and Sarah Hehir
Written by Sarah Hehir
Director – Ursula Martinez
Dramaturg – Dr Frank Peschier
Movement Director – Nevena Stojkov
Composer – Jovana Backovic
Costume Designer – Moa Johansson

MAN OR BEAR
Summerhall at the Edinburgh Fringe
6 to 30 August 2026

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top